I am both the best and the worst gift-giver in the world!
How is it possible to be both? Allow me to explain.
When it comes to the times you people expect gifts, like Christmas, birthdays, other random holidays, I stink. I do not like getting gifts for people just because I’m supposed to get them a gift.
However, when the time comes to give a gift because I care, I shine. I would rather give gifts when people least expect them, because then those gifts come from the heart. For example, when I lived in Japan, I think I missed most of the gift-giving moments, but I spent a lot of time (and in some cases a lot of money) looking for the perfect gift to send the important individuals in my life. In other words, I thought about what each person would want/need/love and never get for him/herself and that is the gift I gave.
At this time of year, when gifts seem more like obligations than signs of caring, there are several questions that drive me crazy:
- What do you want . . .?
- Which one of these do you like?
- Would you like ______ or _______?
If I have to answer a bunch of questions about a gift, then just let me get it myself. It’s almost easier if you give me money or a gift card. Of course, money often feels like it has strings attached. So often, when I get money as a gift, it comes with instructions as to how the giver would like me to spend it. But seriously, if paying an outstanding bill gives me peace of mind, isn’t that just as valuable as treating myself to a day at a spa?
To me, a gift is something you give a person because it makes you think of that person. It is something that the recipient may never get for him/herself, but you know he/she would love.
A gift is thoughtful and from the heart.
Now, this doesn’t mean that I don’t want gifts on my birthday. But, I prefer the gift of having someone remember and care, to anything bought because someone felt obliged to get me a gift. Actually, I’d rather have a thoughtful dinner with friends, or a special day, then an expensive bauble that has more to do with the buyer than me.
So far, during this crazed gift-giving season, the best gift I have received was the holiday card from Mark (aka the Idiot). I know, everyone gets masses of holiday greetings and year-end updates at this time of year (although a lot of ours seem to have been lost in the mail, as the Post Office continues to be abysmal about forwarding letters.) The reason I say this was a special gift is because it signifies the growing friendship with a person that I have only met through words. I was honored to be put on the list, and that felt like a gift.
To me, the rules of gift giving should be as follows:
- give gifts because you feel like giving them, not because you are expected to give them
- give gifts that show you know and care about the recipient, that you had him/her in mind when you found the gift
- the price or size of a gift doesn’t matter, the love and meaning does
- gives should be given without expectation of return
- gifts should have significance or meaning
- the exception to these rules lies in the giving of gifts to thank someone for their hospitality–that’s a slightly different kind of gift giving, which people should do more often. When in doubt, give chocolate
- once a gift is given, the recipient can do with it whatever he/she wants, including spending money or regifting. But, I think there would be a lot less regifting if gifts were given with purpose and meaning.
So, please understand when I don’t give gifts on a holiday which holds little meaning to me, beyond the festive lights, the music, and the atmosphere of chaotic joy. But, don’t be surprised if someday, for no reason, you get a little gift from me, even if it is simply a note of encouragement.
After all, one of my strongest gifts is with words, so if I can’t share those in kindness than I have nothing else to give.
I wish you all a calm and peaceful holiday season, filled with love, warmth, and joy. The only other gift I can offer, right now, is my continued support to this fabulous community of warm, creative people.
It’s a gift from the heart.


Dec 21, 2011 @ 11:47:11
I have told my husband time and time again- the card matters more than anything. One year he gave me a birthday card that he must have just grabbed and not even looked at because it was for a woman, from a woman. He rued that day he did that. Ever since then, he has tried a little harder, trying to find one that fits, and even gave me the same card two years running (without realizing it) because it was so significant.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 11:49:08
I know exactly what you mean. I can always tell when Nathan ran into the store thinking, “Oh crap, I forgot to get a card” vs. the times when he gets gifts with intent. We have both given up on Valentine’s day because too often that becomes an epic fail.
Dec 22, 2011 @ 10:42:59
yeah…we don’t do Valentine’s either. we do cards, but other than that, we’re married. He doesn’t need to court me on the night when we will wait for hours to get a table at a crappy restaurant. I’d rather go to lunch the next day. Our tax appt is always around Valentine’s so we actually make that our date. How sad is that!?!
Dec 22, 2011 @ 11:05:04
I don’t think it’s sad at all, at least you have a date.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 11:51:05
Nicely said, Lisa. My friend-girl (not sure what we are at this moment, so…) and I were discussing the same thing. The idea of a any gift, anytime, and not when “supposed to”….and it can mean so much more. Her son once made her a cd compilation of all the Beatles songs he knew she liked. She said it means more to her than any “gift” he could have bought for her.
Have a wonderful holiday season (and trip…soon?).
Dec 21, 2011 @ 11:54:31
I actually miss mixed tapes and cds, because those gifts actually require thought and knowledge of what a person likes. It’s too easy to just load up a bunch of random music for someone now, that takes no thought.
I leave on New Year’s Eve.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 12:39:33
Your treasured friendship is a great gift to me. Have a great day Lisa
Dec 21, 2011 @ 13:48:19
Right back at you.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 12:49:25
My husband and I don’t exchange gifts at Christmas, or birthdays for that matter. We just celebrate each other. We were just talking about this last night, about gift giving as an obligation. You put it so well. Do you mind if I put this entry on my blog today, with full credit of course?
Dec 21, 2011 @ 13:48:09
I’d be honored.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 13:10:38
Lisa, you are dear, and I love that about you! I love being a part of this comunity and having you be a part of mine. I guess I’m sharing just how glad I am that we are both parts of the same community. I love sharing that space with you, my friend. Happy Hanukkah and Merry Christmas from Sara and me.
Hugs,
Kathy
Dec 21, 2011 @ 13:47:56
Ditto, Kathy. That’s all I have to say.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 14:34:24
I completely share your gift-giving philosophy, but of course I hadn’t fleshed mine out quite so eloquently! We don’t buy Christmas gifts (or birthday gifts for the most part), but we *do* find special ways to spend time together. It means so much more.
The overall focus on gift quantity vs quality during this season in particular is pretty depressing…
Dec 21, 2011 @ 14:50:22
That sounds delightful. This year seems to particularly manic about buy more, especially in terms of advertising. It is nauseating, in my opinion.
Dec 21, 2011 @ 21:28:27
Yes, yes, yes, and yes. Celebrate people, not things. Have a beautiful, serene holiday.
Dec 22, 2011 @ 11:06:43
You too!
Dec 22, 2011 @ 08:35:10
You have a great guide to gifts! I think being with the special people in your life is the best gift really and we should expres that more. I’ll enjoy unwrapping gifts on Xmas day but will have a lovely time with my family, which in the end means more and that memory will last longer than the perfume
Dec 22, 2011 @ 11:05:27
Enjoy your day with your family, Vicky.
Dec 22, 2011 @ 14:54:04
I wish you and your family a calm and peaceful holiday season, too.
Dec 22, 2011 @ 17:09:09
Thanks Sparks. Happy Holidays.
Dec 22, 2011 @ 15:50:59
I find getting presents at Christmas & on my birthday really embarrassing. I don’t know why but I do. I love your rules & agree to them. I love getting a surprise gift but I also like giving them. It is the look on folks faces that I really like!
Dec 22, 2011 @ 17:08:52
Embarrassing explains it, especially if it is a gift you have to “pretend” to like.
Dec 24, 2011 @ 15:04:51
Lisa, I think this is much more sweet than my lazy gift-card giving ways. I’m always so thrilled to get a gift that is personal, meant for me, that it hardly matters what it costs or what it is
Dec 24, 2011 @ 15:20:07
Thanks, Tori. I think you will have a lot of personal, meant for you gifts this year.
Dec 26, 2011 @ 12:17:45
I’d say you are a great gift giver……this post is an example. I agree, whole-heartily.
Dec 26, 2011 @ 12:18:53
Thank you. Your words are a gift as well.
Jan 05, 2012 @ 15:01:03
Too true, Lisa (catching up yet again after my holiday hiatus). My absolute favourite gift this year was a five dollar repair job on the teapot I bought in Japan and promptly broke. Special people snuck the pot out, found a retired gentleman who repairs them at home, had it repaired and took me there to pick it up. I was so excited! Though I couldn’t agree with you more, I find it hard to put into practice with nephews I see twice a year and the like.