Why Write? A Reflection on Writing vs. Talking

Writing

Writing (Photo credit: jjpacres)

Over the past couple of weeks I’ve been meeting with a few students who wanted the opportunity to revise their midterm take-home essay exams because they were not satisfied with their grades.  As I sat down with each one to go over their paper, I realized that, for the most part, they understood the material and could express their ideas clearly when talking to me about them. The problem came when they tried to put their words in writing. They simply cannot express themselves as clearly or logically in a written form.

After talking to these students, I returned home to my 9-year-old daughter who moans, groans and complains every time she has to write a paragraph–and she has a lot of paragraphs to write this year. “I don’t know what to say,” she says. “Can you help me?”

“What do you have to write about?”

Sometimes it is a response to a reading, or a prompt to use her imagination and tell a creative story. I will ask her questions, and she can (usually) answer them. If she can’t answer them, I tell her to reread the passage, and then she is able to answer well. In terms of creativity I’ve heard her make up stories inspired by something small, and sat through endless puppet shows created by her and her friends. She has also written numerous poems that you can find sprinkled throughout my blog posts. But, when it comes to assignments for school, she struggles. Her topic sentences are often vague. Her supporting details are sometimes weak. Her concluding sentences non-existent.

Like the college students, she struggles with conveying ideas in a written form.

As a teacher, I’ve often struggled with my own inability to understand why people have difficulty writing. I know, it sounds naive, because everyone has skills that differ from each other. But expressing myself in words has always come naturally to me. When talking to these students or my daughter, they express themselves in words. So why, I wonder, is it so difficult to put those words onto the page?

It’s possible, I suppose, that the difference lies in how people use their brains. The students that I have been working with are predominantly business majors, so I am sure their comfort with numbers, statistics, and graphs is much higher than my own.

But still, that doesn’t explain the gap between the ability to talk fluently about something and the ability to write eloquently and logically about the same topic.

Perhaps the difference lies in how we perceive writing. To me writing is part of my thought process. When I need to work through a problem or an issue, I write. When I am frustrated or angry about something, I write. At times I have even written letters or e-mails to explain an important issue to someone. I am more confident in my ability to express myself in writing than I am in my ability to talk.

Why? Well, as a talker I have a few habits that I have never successfully broken, especially if I am nervous:

  • I giggle
  • I talk with my hands
  • I pace.

In other words, I do all the things I shouldn’t do if I want to be a great speaker. Somehow these habits in addition to my short stature makes me seem less authoritative even when I am the expert in the room.

However, when I write nobody knows what I look like. Nobody hears the giggles or sees the talking hands. Nobody notices my quirks and my pacing.

When I write, I become the speaker I wish I could be.

For me writing is my language of comfort. For my students they communicate in other ways. In Introductory Theater courses I usually give an option for my projects which allows for any type of presentation; including written papers, performed scenes, artistic projects, etc. I try to leave it open-ended to allow for the variety of learners that come to my classes.  For this upper-division course, however, which is filled with seniors, I am requiring written research/analysis papers as their final project.

Am I doing them an injustice by demanding that they express themselves in writing?

These are students who will soon walk out into the world. Most of them will enter the world of business. Most of them will never have to write another long paper. They’ ll never have to do library research. They’ll never have to turn in a written document with a well-thought out argument.

But then again, maybe they will. If they want to move up in the business world, they need to be able to express themselves clearly. They need to be able to write  well-constructed letters; develop well-thought out and researched reports. They need to be able to express themselves in ways beyond the numbers and graphs.

In other words, they need to be able to write.

And I need to be able to speak the words I write.

We all have something to learn.

 

 

8 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. lisaspiral
    Oct 25, 2012 @ 14:34:22

    I always thought that the reason I did so well in college wasn’t because I had a good grasp of the material but because I could write clearly. Getting a blue book and a question meant trying to put thoughts together in a limited time frame on the topic. I didn’t struggle with this (even when I had no clue what the answer to the question actual might be.) I know many of my fellow students did. I don’t think todays students understand that all of their electronic interactions are actually writing. Maybe if they did they’d be more willing to learn to do it better.

    Reply

    • Lisa Wields Words
      Oct 25, 2012 @ 15:50:38

      To be fair, this group has been very polite and proper in their e-mail correspondence with me (which hasn’t happened in a while). But at least one of them said they hadn’t written a paper since they were freshman. I find that truly troubling.

      Reply

  2. Kathryn McCullough
    Oct 25, 2012 @ 14:42:48

    I’m like you, Lisa. If I need to work through something–anything almost–I need to write. In fact, I tell Sara often that I can’t understand her not having this need. I ask her how do she solves problems without writing. Her answer–I don’t know. I don’t get it. However, I think you are actually doing your students a favor by making them write.
    Hugs,
    Kathy

    Reply

  3. Sandra Tyler (@SFiberworks)
    Oct 25, 2012 @ 16:52:04

    Interesting points. I think a lot may have to do too with how much time kids spend playing video games vs. reading.

    Reply

    • Lisa Wields Words
      Oct 25, 2012 @ 16:55:27

      That’s a distinct possibility. With my daughter, she wants things done quickly and right the first time so that she can move onto doing whatever it is she is more interested in doing (sometimes that is video games, other times reading or drawing or watching tv, on rare occasions writing something completely different). It’s frustrating because she knows how much time I spend writing.

      Reply

  4. termitespeaker
    Oct 25, 2012 @ 16:58:18

    I’m similar to you, Lisa – I could always write better than speak. I loved writing term papers in college – if there was a choice between a term paper and a written test, I always took the term paper. And I was never any good in informal discussion classes. I dreaded being called on – my attitude was, if I have something to say, I’ll raise my hand; otherwise, just let me sit here and absorb knowledge.
    And I can’t believe students don’t have to write these days. You’re absolutely right – they are going to have to write more than they know when they get into those business jobs. And even hard science scholars have to be able to write up their discoveries in good English (or whatever language).

    Reply

    • Lisa Wields Words
      Oct 25, 2012 @ 17:00:51

      I’m in this strange position where I have to speak a lot, but I would love to just write my way through the day. Once, several years ago, in a Freshman Composition class I gave an assignment to an accounting major where she had to find out how much writing was involved in accounting. She was VERY surprised. Score one for me.

      Reply

Share your thoughts with Lisa

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: